Neutrals: Selecting the Right Neutral Pigment for Your Palette

10
Plein air painting "End of Summer, Ship Harbor" by Mitchell Albala

Mitchell Albala, End of Summer, Ship Harbor, oil on panel, 5.5″ x 8. By adding a single neutral pigment to my palette, I can create neutral mixtures more quickly. Additionally, I can pick a neutral with a color bias that leans toward the color direction of my piece. In this piece my “go-to” neutral was Portland Gray Deep.

Just about any palette, even a limited palette, will include at least one version of each of the three primaries — a red, a blue, and a yellow. Theoretically, by mixing these primaries together, in various proportions, you can create a wide variety of neutral colors (grays) which can also be used to neutralize other mixtures. But that’s a lot of extra mixing. Many painters like to include at least one neutral color on their palette — a single “go-to” pigment that can quickly be added to other mixtures to make them more neutral.

What is a neutral color? A true neutral would have no color or temperature bias at all. You would have a hard time identifying whether it leaned toward the warm side or the cool side. It would also be difficult to tell what its intrinsic hue was. However, just about any neutral pigment, even black, has a color bias to some degree. The color bias is important because it will influence your mixtures in specific ways. For example, if I am painting a cool blue-gray landscape like End of Summer (above), I will pick a neutral pigment that is cooler (like Gamblin’s Portland Gray Deep), as opposed to a neutral that is warmer, such as burnt umber. In other words, the choice of a neutral pigment is not arbitrary; I choose it based on the color and temperature direction of my painting.

Another reason I like having neutral pigments on my palette is because, by making it easier to mix neutral colors, I am more likely to do so. With so many primary colors on my palette (ultramarine blue, cadmiums, alizarin, etc.), it’s easy to forget just how important neutral colors are in creating shadows and colors that look natural and convincing.

Let’s take a closer look at the individual characteristics of these “go-to” neutrals.

Burnt umberBurnt Umber – This earth color has been my neutral of choice for many years. Straight from the tube burnt umber is dark and chocolate-colored. As you lighten it with white, however, you will see that is has a subtle orange-red tint. Whenever I introduce this pigment to students, I always remind them that it’s not meant to serve as a generic “brown” color for things like tree trunks or soil. Rather, it is used to modify other mixtures and make them less intense.

 

burnt umber and ultramarine make rich blackBurnt umber partners very well with ultramarine blue. When it is added with equal parts of ultramarine (right), it yields a deep, dark  mixture which is as dark as black. This “rich black” can be pushed toward the cool side with a little extra blue or pushed toward the warm side with a little more burnt umber. Thus, with just burnt umber as your single neutral pigment you can create both cool or warm neutrals.

 

 

 

Black – For some painters, black is their de facto neutral. It can also be used as a universal darkening agent — which I believe is a bad habit. When used sparingly it does effectively neutralize a mixture, but when used in larger amounts, it has a tendency to overly darken and deaden color mixtures, bringing a lifeless gray to everything it touches. Why risk this when there are so many interesting neutrals with a subtle color bias?

Payne's GrayPayne’s Gray (right) – As compared to black, Payne’s Gray is cooler and bluer. Straight from the tube, it looks just like black. As white is added, it’s bluish tint becomes obvious. This might be the pigment of choice if you want a black-like pigment with a stronger color bias than regular black.

 

 

Gamblin’s Portland Grays – Gamblin Artist’s Colors offers a wide range of neutral pigments called Portland Grays. (Gamblin is based in Portland, Oregon.)

Gamblin's Portland Gray light, medium and deepPortland Gray in light, medium, or deep (right) – These grays are formulated to be unbiased neutrals; that is, without any color or temperature shift in either direction. To my eye, however, they appear slightly cool. The swatch at right is Portland Gray Deep. Portland Grays are comprised of mars black and iron oxide (umber) pigments.

 

Light-value Neutrals

Most of the neutrals mentioned so far are quite dark. What if you want to generate a neutral mixture, but don’t necessarily want to darken that mixture at the same time? That’s where the light value neutrals come in.

Gamblin's Portland Gray warm and cool
Portland Warm Gray and Portland Cool Gray (above)  – These two middle-value pigments make a good pair if you are looking to have both a warm and a cool neutral on your palette. Portland Warm Gray has a red bias. Straight from the tube it appears to have a slight violet cast. Portland Cool Gray has a blue bias.

Gamblin’s Portland Gray Light and Medium – See “Gamblin’s Portland Grays” above.)

Gamblin Warm White and Cool White
Gamblin’s Warm White and Cool White (above) – Gamblin has just introduced a Warm White and a Cool White. The Warm White has a titanium/zinc white base, with very small amounts of hansa yellow and orange for a clean (intense) light white. The Cool White is also made with a titatnium/zinc white base, with the tiniest amount of phthalo blue for a noticeable blue tint. These can be quite handy when mixing warm or cool colors of a very light value. If I am trying to mix, say, a very light orange hue, it might be more efficient to start with Warm White instead of titanium white.

Titanium BuffTitanium Buff – There is a common misperception that Titanium White is made by “bleaching” the more muted Titanium Buff.  In fact, Titanium Buff is made from titanium dioxide, which is a very bright white and the same white that is on most painters’ palettes. What makes Titanium Buff appear muted is that it is compounded with iron oxide. Like Titanium White, Titanium Buff is opaque and has strong covering power.

As luscious as these neutral pigments are, don’t go overboard with them. Your cool and warm primary and secondary colors will always be the mainstay of your palette. Your neutral pigments, perhaps one or two at most, augment the palette by helping you mix neutrals that fit the color scheme of your painting.


Additional Resources

The “Expanded Primaries” Palette — Thinking About Cool and Warm

Share.

About Author

Mitchell Albala is the author of Landscape Painting: Essential Concepts and Techniques for Plein Air and Studio Practice (Watson-Guptill, 2009). A best-seller with over 35,000 copies in print, it has been called the "new classic of landscape." A respected teaching artist for more than 25 years, Mitchell currently teaches at Gage Academy of Art in Seattle, Pacific Northwest Art School, Winslow Art Center, and Arte Umbria in Italy. He has also lectured at the Seattle Art Museum and written for International Artist and Artists & Illustrators magazines.

10 Comments

  1. This latest post is very interesting to me as I am struggling with this issue in my watercolour work. Do you happen to know how to use Neutral Tint (a Winsor + Newton Artist’s Grade Watercolour)? Why is it called Neutral Tint and what is it used for? Does it fit into any of the categories discussed in your post?

  2. Mitchell Albala on

    Catherine — Ah, you’re testing the limits of my knowledge, as I am not a watercolorist. However, a quick Google search yields this this little tidbit from the ASW Express website: Neutral tint is “an opaque, deep gray with a very slight blue-violet undertone. Used to dull or darken colours, excellent for shadow mixes.” Of course, I haven’t tried it but it sounds similar to the Payne’s Gray I discussed in the post. Although watercolor is an entirely transparent medium, the idea that neutral pigments will neutralize more saturated colors will hold true. Although they call it “neutral tint” it is nothing more than a variety of pigment combinations that add up to a neutral color, much like the Portland Grays discussed in the article. The site reports that it’s made up of these pigment combinations: Copper Phthalocyanine, PB15; Carbon Black, PBk6; Quinacridone, PV19.

  3. Mitchell Albala on

    Gamblin makes a Titanium Buff, but so do many other manufacturers. The “Portland Grays” are a Gamblin exclusive.

  4. Linda Anderson on

    Hi Mitch,

    Thank you for the very informative post. I have your book which I often refer to.

  5. Mitchell Albala on

    Thanks, Mary, for spreading the word. Please continue to enjoy the blog. Many more interesting articles to come …

  6. I’ve been trying Cobra water mixable oils and am having trouble because they are so wet and take so long to get to a stage where I can soften the edges, is there anything that can help the drying time speed up?
    Thanks Kathy scott

  7. Mitchell Albala on

    Unfortunately, I don’t have much experience with water-based oils. I would imagine, however, that each manufacturer has some kind of drying medium. I’d look for that. Good luck.