In this third and final installment in the Color Strategies series, I demonstrate that a neutral palette, with its ability to unify disparate colors, can be considered a color strategy in its own right.
In Parts 1 and 2 we saw that the use of a structured color plan or strategy could help build greater color harmony and suggest a unified light. We find that analogous colors, because they are so closely allied on the color wheel, form very close-knit harmonies. With complementary colors, we find harmony through opposition (radiant complements) and harmony through their mixture, which form neutrals. In this final article, we will look more closely at neutral colors and see how they may be considered a color strategy in their own right.
If we asked several painters to name a few color strategies, they might say triadic, complementary, split-complementary, or analogous. But it is unlikely they would name “neutral” as a strategy. However, the paintings featured in this article will demonstrate that, when paintings are composed primarily of neutral tones, a relatedness among the colors is formed. And, as we have seen throughout this series, where we find relatedness among colors, we find harmony.
Don’t underestimate the power of neutral colors. Although neutrals don’t shout as loudly as bright colors do — they prefer to whisper — they are just as capable of expressing effective color relationships.
A Unity Among Neutrals
Any individual color or mixture has a relative intensity, ranging from very bright and intense to very dull and neutral. Strictly defined, “neutral” means the absence of color. In the context of this article, however, I use the word neutral more generally to mean any color that is less than fully saturated. Only an absolute neutral would have no color bias at all; it would be a perfect gray. The key point for the neutral strategy is this: as colors become increasingly neutral they begin to harmonize through a common association to that absolute neutral baseline. Thus, colors that might be dissimilar or discordant in a more saturated color field are “calmed” down and better able to agree with each other when they are neutralized.
This is demonstrated in these three color swatches. Each pair is comprised of the same two hues — red-violet and green. In the top pair, the colors are pure and saturated. They have little in common and do not form a particularly unified pairing. They even vibrate a bit from some complementary action. In the second row, the colors are more desaturated and seem to contrast less. In the third row, the colors are very desaturated and only retain a hint of their original hue — yet are considerably more harmonious and unified than the saturated pair.
Because we have such a positive emotional response to color, there is a bias toward brighter, more saturated color. As a result, the neutral strategy is often under-appreciated. The five contemporary landscape painters featured here show that paintings employing the neutral strategy possess emotional depth and a contemplative quality. We will also see that the neutral strategy does not mean the absence of color. Although neutrals don’t shout as loudly as bright colors do — they prefer to whisper — they are just as capable of expressing effective color relationships.
Veil Falls achieves a unity of color through a common association to an absolute “no color” gray. The color map for the painting shows 25 representative colors from the painting. There are subtle cool and warm shifts, and hue shifts toward blue or green, yet all are unified by a common association to the neutral gray.
Solmssen typically works with much brighter colors than we see in Snow on 7th Street. But neutral colors are a fitting choice for this wintery scene. The color swatches isolate nine representative colors from the major areas of the painting. Although the colors are significantly desaturated, we can see that a neutral-based strategy does not mean the absence of color, but more subtle color. Solmssen strikes a clear temperature shift between the lights and darks: the lightest values in the snow and sky, along with the terra cotta-colored houses, are warm, while the distant shore and large tree are relatively cooler. In the “gray” water there is a delicate commingling of the pale blue and pale orange. In a painting that is built on a neutral strategy, the painter may use more neutral pigments.
Muccillo is one of many painters working in the contemporary tonalist tradition, a style that emerged with the painters of the Hudson River School, who used a blanket of tone to suggest colored atmosphere or mist. Tonalist painters rarely dip into highly saturated colors; instead, their palettes are laden with earth tones and subdued mixtures that help establish a harmony of neutrals. This neutral tonality, in combination with strong value contrasts, helps convey the deep sense of mood these paintings are known for. Remarkably, in The Upward Push, Muccillo uses just five colors on his palette — titanium white, ivory black, transparent earth yellow, viridian green, and dioxazine purple. Such a restricted set of pigments — a limited palette — helps ensure that color mixtures remain simple and more closely related. As Solmssen does in Snow on 7th Street, Muccillo pays close attention to temperature differences — a largely cool sky poised over a largely warm ground.
Skorut also works in the contemporary tonalist tradition. His palette includes many earth tones — pigments like burnt umber, yellow ochre, Naples yellow, and raw sienna. In this piece, however, he expands beyond the earth tones to include more saturated colors in the sky. This demonstrates a very important lesson: a neutral harmony does not prohibit the use of more saturated colors. In fact, when poised against neutral colors, brighter areas of color will appear much stronger, and neutral areas much more neutral.
Painter T. Allen Lawson builds harmony in many of his paintings with a delicate orchestration of neutral hues. In South Thomaston Church, we observe a very unified color-light and a very obvious atmosphere. There are subtle temperature shifts everywhere, such as between the light warm blue of the foreground snow and the pale light yellow of the church. That these colors are fairly neutral help them relate in a way that suggests a uniform light. The sense of atmosphere is also heightened by a limited range of values.
Find out more about the artist featured in this article: